Assessing Chemistry Laboratory Skills Through a Competency‑based Approach in High School Chemistry Course

  • Lucila Giammatteo Chemistry Department, Facultad de Estudios Superiores Cuautitlán, Univerisdad Nacional Autónoma de México
  • Adolfo V. Obaya Instituto Superior de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey, Campus Estado de México

Abstract

The present paper offers a competency-based approach to evaluate high school laboratory skills during a chemistry course. The Secretaría de Educación Pública (Mexico’s Ministry of Education) has identified experimental sciences specific competencies that are to be established in high school. This study investigated the following competencies: Formulating scientific questions, posing hypothesis, obtaining and registering information, applying safety norms in handling substances, materials and equipment, conducting practical activities appropriately in the laboratory, handling residues, collecting qualitative and quantitative data, contrasting results, communicating conclusions, and documenting information sources. An assessment tool where the students’ level of achievements was created. This assessment tool evaluated these competencies by considering the curriculum and the students’ graduate profile. Results indicated that by having a consistent evaluation plan and providing students with effective feedback, the students competency levels addressed in laboratory practical’s can be improved significantly.

Author Biography

Adolfo V. Obaya, Instituto Superior de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey, Campus Estado de México
CHEMISTRY DEPARTMENT PROFESSOR TITULAR C

References

• ARELLANO, M., LAZO, S. (1999). Evaluación del logro de las competencias básicas en el laboratorio de química general. Evaluación Educativa. 49-53.

• COUCH, B., BROWN, T., SCHELPAT, T:, GRAHAM, M. AND KNIGHT, J. (2015) Scientific Teaching: Defining a Taxonomy of Observable Practices. CBE-Life Sciences Education 14, 1-12

• ECHEVERRY, E., ARENAS, W., BOHORQUEZ, N. (2015). Implementación de laboratorios lúdicos para la evaluación por competencias desde un enfoque constructivista. Educación en Ingeniería. 10 (20). 123 – 132.

• FALENDER, C. AND SHAFRANSKE, E. (2007) Competence in Competency-Based supervisión Practice: Construct and Application. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 38, (3) 232-240

• FRADE, L. (2009). Desarrollo de competencias en educación básica. Calidad Educativa Consultores. México, D.F.

• GAVILAN, I., CANO, S., ABURTO, S. (2013). Diseño de herramientas didácticas basado en competencias para la enseñanza de química ambiental. Educ. Quím. 24 (3) 298 – 308.

• GONCZI, A. (1994) Competency based assessment in professions in Australia. Assessment in Education 1, 27-44

• FALENDER, C. AND SHAFRANSKE, E. (2007) Competence in Competency-Based supervisión Practice: Construct and Application. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 38, (3) 232-240

• MONZO, R. (2009). Evaluación basada en competencias. Revista Panamericana de Pedagogía 131-144.

• MORENO, T. (2012). La evaluación de competencias en la educación. Sinéctica 39 1-22.

• MUÑOZ, F., MEDINA, A., GUILLEN, M. (2015). Jerarquización de competencias genéricas basadas en las percepciones de docentes universitarios. Educ. Quím. 27 126 – 132.

• OBAYA, A., PONCE, R. (2010). Evaluación del aprendizaje basado en el desarrollo de competencias. ContactoS 76, 31-37.

• ROGERS, I. (2001) Integrated Learning Systems- an open approach. International Journal of Science Education 23, (4), 405-422

• SECRETARIA DE EDUCACION PUBLICA. SEP. (2008). Reforma Integral de Educación Media Superior (RIEMS). Acuerdo 444.

Retrieved from: http://dof.gob.mx/nota_detalle.php?codigo=5061936&fecha=26/09/2008, on December 15th, 2017.

• SHAFI, R. IRSHAD, K., IQBAL, M. (2010). Competency – based integrated practical examinations: Bringing relevance to basic science laboratory examinations. Medical Teacher. 32, 443-447.

• THOMPSON, K., CHMIELEWSKI, J., GAINES, M., HRYCYNA, C. AND LACOURSE, W. (2013) Competency-Based Reforms of Undergraduate Biology Sciences. CBE-Life Sciences Education 12, 162-169

• VELDE, C. (1999) An alternative conception of competence: implications for vocational education. Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 51, 3, 437-447

• WESTERA, W. (2001) Competences in education: a confusión of tongues. Journal of Curriculum Studies 33, 1, 75-88

Published
2018-05-27